18.11.2026 12:14

From ‘paper parks’ to real protection

Velká Británie Newcastle University Autor neuveden
Newcastle University researchers Francesca Trotman and Professor Per Berggren analysed more than 200 publications to create a practical roadmap for making Marine Protected Areas effective, rather than “paper parks.” Their four-stage framework covers ecological and socioeconomic data, Indigenous and community engagement, suitable location and connectivity, and management, funding, monitoring and enforcement. The work comes as nearly 200 countries pursue the 30x30 target, while only 10% of oceans are currently protected and studies have classified 27% of MPAs as ineffective.
AI shrnutí

Newcastle University research offers a roadmap for turning global ocean protection goals into action.

As the world works towards protecting 30% of the planet’s land and sea by 2030, the study highlights why the success of Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) depends not just on how much ocean is designated for protection, but on how these areas are planned, governed, monitored and enforced.

Publishing in the Journal of Environmental Management, Francesca Trotman and Professor Per Berggren analysed over 200 publications to develop a practical, step-by-step guide to help MPAs deliver meaningful benefits for marine biodiversity and habitats, rather than remaining protected only in theory.

In 2022, almost 200 countries committed to protecting 30% of the planet’s land and sea by 2030, now known as the 30x30 target. Since then, MPAs have been firmly in the spotlight, with the High Seas Treaty entering into force earlier this year and discussions continued at COP17. Despite this momentum, only 10% of our oceans are currently protected. While MPAs can play a key role in protecting threatened habitats and species, and boost biodiversity, studies have classified an astounding 27% of MPAs as ineffective ‘paper parks’- areas that look protected on paper but fall woefully short of their goals in reality.

To help address these issues, the authors have developed a practical roadmap, built around four key topic areas that they identified as essential for MPA success from their literature review, and combining with free tools and real-world case studies

The four-stage framework is based on integrating ecological and socioeconomic data from the outset, including scientific research and local ecological knowledge. The authors stress that MPAs need to be designed around the specific ecological and social conditions of each location, rather than following a one-size-fits-all approach.

The four-stage framework

Evaluation of Integrated Ecological and Socioeconomic Data

At this first stage, practitioners need to address some key questions, including why an MPA is needed, and what are its principles, goals and objectives. This stage also includes collating existing ecological data and filling data gaps. The authors recommend the integration of local ecological knowledge, for example from fishers who’ve worked the same waters for generations and have valuable information about historical fish populations, spawning grounds and fish seasonal movements.

Indigenous Engagement, Relationship Mapping and Governance

The authors emphasise that understanding the socio-economic context of a particular area and communities dependent on it can help create an inclusive MPA, which will likely increase compliance with implemented regulations. MPAs don’t exist in isolation. People depend on these areas for food, livelihoods, recreation and cultural identity. Time and again, the science has shown that effective MPAs involve local communities throughout the process.

Effective Location, Connectivity and Cover

Spatial planning is an important step in designing an MPA, while stakeholder consultation is essential to ensure the proposed MPA reflects available scientific information and stakeholder needs. MPAs must consider important habitats, species movements, fishing grounds and surrounding communities. The right design depends on the ecosystem and the people who depend on it. Where and how to protect oceans matters as much as the size of areas protected.

Regulatory Management, Costs, Enforcement and Policy Framework

The final stage addresses the need to implement a widely accepted and functional enforcement strategy, which requires a realistic budget, monitoring, and publication and outreach around the MPA. Crucially, monitoring must inform decisions. If something is not working, management needs to adapt. Limited funding remains a major obstacle. Despite covering 71% of our planet, oceans receive less than 1% of global philanthropic funding and Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 14, Life Below Water is the most underfunded SDG.

Francesca Trotman, a PhD Marine Science researcher at Newcastle University’s School of Natural and Environmental Sciences, said: “We have the knowledge, now let’s use it. The ambition to protect more of the oceans is important, but we need to be equally ambitious about the effectiveness of that protection. We need to learn from what is working, improve what is not, and ensure new MPAs are more than another box ticked on a government report. That is why we have compiled the evidence, tools and case studies into an accessible roadmap for conservationists, policymakers and organisations worldwide. Or paper is fully open access, which means it is free for anyone to download and use, because the ocean needs everyone.”

Per Berggren, Emeritus Professor of Marine Megafauna Conservation, School of Natural & Environmental Sciences, Newcastle University, added: "We recommend future research that adapts the roadmap we have developed to open ocean MPAs. Our roadmap can be tailored to reflect local conditions and new scientific findings to support conservation efforts. This adaptive approach increases the sustainability of MPAs, contributes to the protection of marine ecosystems globally and helps eliminate ‘paper parks’."

Reference

Trotman, F.G.V. and Berggren, P. (2026) ‘A roadmap for effective and sustainable marine protected areas: Beyond paper parks’, Journal of Environmental Management, 401, article 128956. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2026.128956

Image: Love The Oceans team removes a huge industrial ghost net the size of 2 double decker busses from the ocean. This photo shows approximately half of what was removed. Photo credit: Francesca Trotman


https://www.ncl.ac.uk/press/articles/latest/2026/11/marineprotectedareas

Autor
Společnost / Organizace
Newcastle University
Stáhnout
Sdílet
Galerie