Dawn raids, messaging apps and the EUR 1 million fine
The Romanian Competition Council (RCC) can fine companies for obstructing dawn raids, independently of the outcome of competition investigations; under Romanian law, procedural infringements can attract fines of up to 1% of worldwide turnover. In September 2026, the RCC announced a fine of about RON 5.2 million (EUR 1 million) after an employee uninstalled a work messaging app during an inspection, restricting access to potentially relevant information. The RCC has also sanctioned companies for denying access to email accounts and correspondence, including a total fine of about RON 14.3 million imposed on three companies in connection with inspections in March 2023. The release advises companies to prepare staff and procedures to preserve business records and cooperate with inspectors.
October 2026 – Companies can face substantial fines for obstructing a dawn raid, irrespective of the outcome of the underlying competition investigations.
Following the first obstruction fines in 2008, companies generally cooperated with inspectors from the Romanian Competition Council (“RCC”) and further sanctions of this kind remained rare for many years. More recently, some companies have tested specific aspects of the inspectors’ powers and the scope of their duty to cooperate, with the courts generally upholding the authority’s position.
Recent RCC cases have focused on access to emails and business communications, including those held on mobile devices. Companies should check that their response procedures cover these issues and that employees understand what is expected of them during an inspection.
Conduct that can amount to obstruction
RCC dawn raids generally require an inspection order issued by the authority’s president and prior judicial authorisation. Companies must cooperate with inspectors acting within the scope of the inspection.
Refusing access to premises or business records, providing incomplete information or documents and breaking seals can all lead to sanctions. The same applies to failing to answer questions within the scope of the inspection or giving incomplete, inaccurate or misleading answers. Deleting business messages or uninstalling an application used for work may also restrict access to evidence and expose the company to a fine.
Under the Romanian Competition Law, procedural infringements of this kind may be sanctioned with fines of up to 1% of the undertaking’s total worldwide turnover in the financial year preceding the sanction. Liability may arise from intentional conduct or negligence and is separate from any liability for the suspected competition infringement.
Examples from RCC enforcement
- Uninstalling a messaging app. In September 2026, the RCC announced a fine of approx. RON 5.2 million (approx. EUR 1 million) for providing incomplete information and documents during a dawn raid. According to the RCC, an employee uninstalled a messaging app from a mobile device used for work after being informed of the inspection, restricting access to potentially relevant information.
- Access to email accounts and correspondence. Three companies belonging to the same group were fined approx. RON 14.3 million in total (approx. EUR 2.9 million) for denying access to certain email accounts and correspondence during inspections in March 2023. In September 2026, the RCC reported that the Bucharest Tribunal had upheld, by final judg ment, the RON 9.9 million fine imposed on one of the companies. It also announced that it had won the challenges brought by the other two companies.
- Access to a director’s email account. In January 2022, the RCC announced a fine of approx. RON 0.4 million (approx. EUR 90,000) for refusing inspectors’ access to the email account of the company’s director.
- Delayed access to premises. The RCC imposed a fine of approx. RON 19 million (approx. EUR 5.4 million) after inspectors were denied access to a company’s headquarters for approx. two hours in 2008. The fine was later substantially reduced by the court.
- Refusal to submit to an inspection. In June 2008, the RCC fined a company approx. RON 1.5 million (approx. EUR 400,000) for refusing to submit to a dawn raid. The courts subsequently upheld the fine.
Cooperation during an inspection
The following main points draw on the RCC’s enforcement practice and the Romanian rules on inspections:
- legal counsel should be contacted as soon as inspectors arrive. Counsel’s presence is not a condition for the inspection to proceed and only a short delay for consultation may generally be accepted before records are examined;
- inspectors can examine business records regardless of how they are stored. Where a personal device is also used for work, the business communications on it may fall within the scope of the inspection. Personal devices would nonetheless require specific court authorisation;
- IT staff may be required to explain the company’s systems, help locate records and carry out specific technical tasks requested by inspectors. They should be available throughout the inspection;
- employees should be instructed promptly to preserve relevant records. Deleting messages, uninstalling applications or otherwise altering data during an inspection may expose the company to a fine.
Legal counsel should coordinate the response to requests and address any issues concerning the scope of the inspection, legal privilege or personal data as they arise.
Practical steps for businesses
Companies should consider the following measures to prepare for and respond to a dawn raid:
- a written dawn raid procedure should identify who will coordinate the response and how to reach the relevant management, legal, compliance and IT contacts. It should also cover employees working remotely;
- training should reach the employees likely to be involved, including reception and IT staff. A practical exercise can help establish whether they know whom to contact and how to deal with inspectors’ requests;
- rules on business communications should cover personal devices and messaging applications, as well as approved company systems. Retention and automatic deletion settings should allow relevant records to be preserved when required;
- employees should be told to answer questions accurately, avoid speculation and seek clarification where needed. Any concerns about the scope of a request should be raised with legal counsel;
- the company should keep a record of the inspectors’ requests, the explanations provided and the documents copied, together with any objections raised during the inspection.
Information collected by other public authorities
In a press release of 8 October 2026, the RCC reported that the Romanian Constitutional Court had upheld the provision in the Competition Law allowing it to use information and documents collected by other public authorities and institutions in the course of their activities, subject to the conditions laid down by law. The ruling was delivered in litigation concerning the RCC’s 2018 fines for bid rigging in public tenders for gas transmission pipeline works.
The ruling confirms that information obtained by another authority, including the criminal authorities, may therefore also be used in an RCC investigation, subject to the applicable legal conditions and rights of defence.
Concluding remark
Companies should check that their dawn raid procedures reflect how employees actually communicate and work, including their use of messaging apps and personal devices. Employees need to understand what to preserve and how to respond to inspectors, as their actions during an inspection may expose the company to a substantial fine of its own.
https://www.kinstellar.com/news-and-insights/detail/4807/dawn-raids-messaging-apps-and-the-eur-1-million-fine